At this point, there is no single solution. There are a number of solutions that must be vetted and more investigation is likely going to be necessary. At this point we have a reading of the ossuary that has been put forth by Simcha and Tabor, and others are now weighing in and presenting their views since this is all new information for all of us.
I hope that we don't make a war out of this, but can proceed with caution, logic, collegiality and professionalism.
Let's get all the options out on the table, and talk them through. The Jonah option is one. The vase is another. I think these are the two most logical options at this moment. What do the ossuary experts say when this image is compared to ossuary art? We need funerary context to figure this out.
James Tabor writes in the comments to my previous post on this subject:
Yuval...has said of all the ossuaries in the Bet Shemesh/Rockefeller collection (upwards of 1500 now I think--as Rahmani only goes back to 1989), with at least 350 inscribed (estimate based on Cotton, CIIP) he has never seen anything like our image, that it is definitely not a nephesh or a vessel of any time known on ossuaries. He thinks the fish/Jonah suggestion is the most convincing yet.Tabor also writes about the image in the same comment on my blog:
What I have said is that none of our photos have been altered, doctored, or photoshopped in any way. They are precisely the images the camera produced taken from the hundreds of hours of video tape and freeze frames taken during the actual process. That is what is false, plus the charge/implication that we are dishonest and manipulate evidence to try to fit a theory. Nothing has been touched. There is no single photo showing the entire image, however, by moving the robotic arm in all positions the complete image is visible. In addition to the photos, to allow people to see the entire image at once, there are CGI images produced by GE Information Technologies. These are clearly labeled as such (see thejesusdiscovery.org)...Tom Verenna continues to think it is a vase of some sort and posted a second round of evidence HERE.